[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: ebay dilemma / cdr seller





Luis,

I know your intentions are in the right place here, but I have two
comments:

1. *You* aren't the copyright holder here. This really isn't your
battle.

not even a battle, just a thought. One doesnt see many 'flagrant violations' like that for Apples - but heck that is cuz there is no market, so why bother :-)



2. The collateral damage of you pursuing this is liable to screw up
the What is the Apple IIGS site and whole bunch of others that are
doing good work.

I dont really see the comparison.  Those sites don't SELL disk images, do they?


I think it's best if you just let this one go. It is reasonable to
expend some effort to contact original copyright holders to get
permission to distribute abandoned software (as I did with the entire
Beagle Bros TimeOut series earlier this year), and it's reasonable to
distribute it anyway after due diligence gets no response, but acting
on behalf of the copyright holder (who may intentionally be letting
"this stuff" go on with full unofficial knowledge but remains
officially silent for legal reasons) isn't necessary.

hey I can fully see the other side, a user saying great, I can buy all these programs as disk images. Just retro-hobbyists, so let them / us enjoy!

It was just an odd thought that came up - hey will I be the last person to sell a particular program on floppy before it then shows up on cd-r on ebay? Hence my question.

But as Bill wrote - ship 'em, then it is on the next guy's conscience. Not a big deal.